Badminton How To Play

Thinking about the greatest players in Columbia football history is a bit like that quote I came across recently. Someone was talking about commitment in the face of uncertainty, saying, "Regarding the term, I was thinking, with the uncertainty that comes with age, year-to-year. But in the face of stronger competition, [they] preferred a much longer union." That really struck me. Columbia's program has faced its share of uncertainty and fierce competition over the decades, often as the underdog in the Ivy League. The true legends here aren't just the most talented; they're the ones who forged that "much longer union" with excellence, who delivered consistently and left an indelible mark despite the challenges. They committed to greatness over the long haul. So, pulling from stats, legacy, and my own years following this team, here's my personal look at the top ten Lions to ever don the light blue and white.

Any conversation has to start with Sid Luckman. It's non-negotiable. Before he became a Chicago Bears legend and a Pro Football Hall of Famer, he was revolutionizing the quarterback position right here at Baker Field. In 1938, he led Columbia to its only Rose Bowl appearance, a stunning 7-0 victory over Stanford. People forget how dominant he was; he was a single-wing tailback who could throw with unprecedented accuracy and power. He accounted for over 3,400 yards of total offense in his career, a monstrous number for that era. For me, Luckman isn't just number one on this list, he's in a tier of his own. He transcended the program. Right there with him in that pantheon is the great Lou Kusserow. A single-wing fullback in the late 1940s, he was pure, brutal efficiency. In just 24 games, he scored 32 touchdowns and averaged a ridiculous 6.7 yards per carry. His 156 points in the 1947 season stood as a Columbia record for over half a century. He was the engine of some very strong teams, and when you watch the old footage, his combination of power and speed just jumps off the screen.

Moving into the modern era, the names shift but the standard remains. I have a huge soft spot for Marcellus Wiley, '97. As a defensive end, he was an absolute freak of nature—6'5", 275 pounds of explosive athleticism that the Ivy League simply wasn't prepared for. He recorded 26 sacks in his career, including 13 in his senior season, and forced an incredible 11 fumbles. He didn't just beat blockers; he embarrassed them. Watching him chase down quarterbacks from the backside was a thing of beauty. He parlayed that into a 10-year NFL career, proving Columbia could produce elite professional talent. Then there's John Witkowski, '84. The term "gunslinger" was made for him. He holds virtually every passing record in the book, but the one that always astounds me is his 3,836 passing yards in 1983. In an era where the Ivy League was still heavily run-oriented, Witkowski was slinging it 40-50 times a game. He gave Columbia a puncher's chance every single Saturday, and his arm talent was, frankly, professional-grade.

You can't talk about greatness without the anchors in the trenches. Paul Kaliades, '71, is arguably the finest offensive lineman in school history, a consensus First Team All-American who protected Witkowski's predecessor, Don Jackson. He was the cornerstone. On the other side, Rory Wilfork, '04, was a disruptive force at defensive tackle whose career tally of 20.5 sacks from the interior is just silly. He commanded double-teams every snap. And while we're on defense, let me make a case for a personal favorite: Mike Cavanaugh, '96. A linebacker from that fearsome mid-90s defense alongside Wiley, Cavanaugh was the brains and the brawn. He piled up 395 tackles, still the school record, and had a nose for the ball that was uncanny. He wasn't the biggest or fastest, but he was always, always in the right place. That kind of football IQ is rare.

For leadership and sheer two-way impact, I'd slot in Bill Swiacki, '48. A receiver and defensive back, his most famous moment is "The Catch" in the 1947 Army game—a miraculous, game-winning 21-yard touchdown reception with under a minute to play to beat the mighty Black Knights 21-20. It's the single most iconic play in Columbia history. But he was more than one play; he was a clutch performer and a winner. Rounding out my list are two more modern icons. Sean Brackett, '12, at quarterback, was a dual-threat dynamo who willed some less-talented teams to competitiveness with his heart and his legs, finishing with over 8,500 yards of total offense. And finally, the most recent entry, linebacker Mike Hinton, '18. His 132-tackle senior campaign was a masterpiece of consistency and hard-nosed play. He felt like a throwback, a tackling machine who embodied the grit of Columbia football.

So, there you have it—my ten. Lists like this are always subjective, and I'm sure I've omitted someone another fan would champion. But for me, these players embody that idea of a "longer union" with excellence. They weren't just flashes in the pan; they built legacies. In the face of the inherent uncertainties and stiff competition that define Ivy League football, they chose to be great, week after week, season after season. They didn't just play for Columbia; they helped define what Columbia football could be at its very best. Their stories are the bedrock of the program's identity, reminders that even in a league known for its parity and challenges, individual brilliance can and does shine through.